Jehovah's
Witnesses around the world are at odds with each other over whether
or not they are allowed to vote.
The confusion has been caused by a "Questions from Readers" article
in the 1st November 1999 issue of the Watchtower magazine.
The "reader", (more than likely a Watchtower writer) simply
asks "How do Jehovah's Witnesses view voting?"
Up until now Jehovah's Witnesses have been ordered not
to vote in political elections in order to maintain the organisation's
stance of political neutrality.
Indeed the Watchtower magazine of 15th November 1977
on page 686 says
"The Witnesses are
neutral as to warfare and strife between the nations, as well as
being clean from all political involvement, not
even voting,
because they fulfil Jesus' description of them as being "no part
of the world." (John 17:14)"
But, in the answer
given by the Watchtower magazine, it seems that another change in
doctrine may be being passed down by the "heavenly mother".
For on page 28 of the magazine we read:
As to whether they will
personally vote for someone running in an election, each one
of Jehovah's Witnesses makes a decision based on his Bible-trained
conscience and an understanding of his responsibility to God
and to the State.
And just to make it clearer,
on page 29 we read;
If someone decides
to go to the polling booth, that is his decision. What he
does in the polling booth is between him and his creator.
Of
course, the Watch Tower Society's suggestion that Jehovah's Witnesses
use their "Bible-trained conscience" is just like telling them
to follow the Watch Tower line and not vote in political elections,
but there may be another reason why the society is loosening
its iron-like grip.
Recently, efforts by the society to gain acceptance
and legal recognition in a number of European countries (i.e. Bulgaria)
have come up against some opposition after the government insisted
that for a religion to be recognised by the state, they must allow
their people to vote.
While some are touting this as a change of policy, it
may simply be words to placate the governments, just like the "change" in
the blood doctrine in Bulgaria.
While the context of the whole discussion makes it clear
that voting in politics is plainly WRONG for the Jehovah's Witness,
it seems, in certain situations, they will be allowed to compromise
their faith and act out the process for the sake of the government.
Likely, this "tolerance" will only apply in
such countries.
Time will tell.
For the moment though, thousands of Jehovah's Witnesses
are left uncertain as to whether the rule applies to them or not.
On a number of Internet discussion boards Jehovah's
Witnesses are beginning to argue over whether or not members will
be disfellowshipped for voting.
Once again, in an effort to clarify things, the Watch
Tower Society has created even more of a mess.
Is this really a sign that God is leading them? We will
leave the Bible to answer for us;
"For
God is not the author of confusion,
but of peace, as in all churches of the saints."
1
Corinthians 14:33
|